Power to the people

Voter initiatives present a unique set of challenges and problems. However, their underlying premise, that the people can be a check on government, is a noble one.

And if Utah is going to remain one of 25 states that allow initiatives, it should not declare certain subjects off limits. That seemed to be the message the Utah Supreme Court was sending this week when it granted a stay on a lower court ruling and allowed citizens in Sevier County to forge ahead with a ballot measure on Nov. 4.

That measure will ask Sevier County voters whether local ordinances should be changed to require a public vote before any coal-fired power plant is granted a conditional-use permit. The initiative is backed by a group opposed to Sevier Power Co.'s intentions to acquire such a permit.

A power company attorney had argued that such an ordinance would be the first step down a slippery slope, perhaps one day leading to public votes over whether a particular church should be allowed in a neighborhood. We are sympathetic to the dangers inherent with allowing public votes on zoning matters, which ultimately affect a person's right to do as he wishes with his or her property.

But there are two reasons to reject the power company attorney's argument. The first, and most compelling, is that religion enjoys special protection under the Constitution's First Amendment. Requiring a vote on church locations would, we hope, be declared unconstitutional. The second is that decisions regarding power plants are made by a small group of elected people whose motives could be every bit as impure as what the power company may believe its opponents to be. Why not require the people in favor of coal-fired plants to sell their ideas to the people who will be most affected?

Utah lawmakers are certainly not new to the idea of tweaking the state's initiative laws to keep the public away. Ten years ago, they put a measure on the ballot that requires a two-thirds majority vote to pass any initiative concerning wildlife issues. The worry there was the the public might curtail hunting rights. That measure passed.

Now they have tried to curtail the public's power once again and have been rebuffed. The court's decision sends what we hope is a loud message.

Recent comments

• Story photo

• Most Popular
• Most Commented

1. Deseret News 2008 Mr. Football: Craig Bills
2. 2008 All-State Football Team
3. 2008 Deseret News MVPs always delivered in clutch situations, displayed great leadership
4. Glenn Beck sees new project as 'most important' of his life
5. Collie has made his All-American case
6. Utah State football: Andersen to Boise State: 'Here we come'
7. MSNBC names Buttars 'worst person in world'
8. Hit parade - Box sets and greatest hits
9. Operative budget word: cut
10. BYU, Weber State basketball: Cougars shoot down Wildcats

1. Sore losers won't let go in California 671
2. Elder Joseph B. Wirthlin, oldest apostle, 91, dies at home 252
3. Buttars says bah to 'holiday' greetings 197
4. BYU football: Destination is unknown for Cougars 195
5. Smith's journals made available to public for 1st time 151
6. MSNBC names Buttars 'worst person in world' 140
7. Utah Utes football: Johnson, Sakoda, Whittingham headline All-MWC honors 115
8. Collie has made his All-American case 114
9. USU football: Andersen is the Aggies' new guy 112
10. Benson had it right 107
11. (Stories published in the last five days with the most comments)

• Utah
• Sports
• Business