Utahn protests overriding of states' laws

WASHINGTON — Utah House Majority Leader David Clark, R-Santa Clara, testified before the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee Wednesday on the importance of protecting state government's authority from federal intervention in the ongoing debate on the legal liability of drug manufacturers.

The committee's chairman, Rep. Henry Waxman, D-Calif., held a hearing examining a proposal on whether patients hurt by defective drugs and medical devices would no longer have the ability to seek compensation for their injuries

"Patients who are injured by approved drugs and devices deserve compensation to help them deal with their permanent disabilities, their inability to work and their costly medical procedures," Waxman said. "But the only way patients can obtain compensation is to bring a lawsuit under state law."

There is a proposal for "pre-emption" of state liability with the idea that the Food and Drug Administration's regulation of drugs and medical devices would not allow injured patients from seeking compensation under state law.

Clark spoke on behalf of the National Conference of State Legislatures, where he serves as the standing committee chair. Clark said he wants to see Congress pass a bill that would prohibit federal pre-emption of state laws.

"NCSL is troubled by the growing trend in Congress, the federal agencies and now the United States Supreme Court to pass legislation, promulgate rules and render decisions that have a substantial, detrimental impact on states because of their intrusively preemptive nature," Clark said.

Clark said states solve problems differently than the federal government and when Congress, federal agencies or the Supreme Court override states' policy decisions "the results are significant to states.

"Every state has well developed bodies of product liability and consumer protection laws that may even date back prior to the establishment of FDA as an agency," Clark said, citing some examples of Utah's code.

"Over the last 55 years, the Utah Legislature has refined our product liability statutes and our state courts have addressed issues of product liability, further refining our state common law," Clark said. "As a result, there is a robust body of product liability laws in our state. If these laws are federally pre-empted, more than a half century of discussion and debate on what laws best meet the needs of Utah's citizens and businesses will be totally lost."

---

E-mail: suzanne@desnews.com

Recent comments

• Most Popular
• Most Commented

1. LDS get final OK on project
2. BYU, Utah Utes football: O-lines may be key to MWC race
3. Were Utahns killing-spree victims?
4. Utah Jazz notebook: Celtics, Spurs, Heat join bidding for Maggette
5. College camps help recruits compare schools
6. Current, former Sonics upset by the team's exit
7. Mom charged with negligent homicide in tot's heat-related death in Layton
8. Utah Jazz: Not the only NBA team interested in Maggette
9. Russia's little hero: Ex-Cougar is invited to join Russia's Olympic camp
10. Syracuse High School football players charged in crime spree

1. 'The leader we need is you,' Beck tells 17,000 at BYU 207
2. The case of the anti-Mormons 168
3. Death penalty has purpose 167
4. LDS get final OK on project 162
5. Utah Utes football: Utah's man — Injury-free Johnson rarin' to go for Utes 129
6. BYU, Utah Utes football: O-lines may be key to MWC race 127
7. Russia's little hero: Ex-Cougar is invited to join Russia's Olympic camp 117
8. GOP, Big Oil push shale in Utah 95
9. Mom charged with negligent homicide in tot's heat-related death in Layton 85
10. Texas county doesn't want FLDS raid costs 74
11. (Stories published in the last five days with the most comments)

• A & E
• LDS news
• Sports